An Exploratory Study: "Blind-Testing" Consumers How They Rate Helpfulness of Online Reviews
نویسندگان
چکیده
Amazon.com uses the helpfulness vote (H-Vote) on consumer product reviews to signal quality. The top reviews with the best H-Vote are thus prominently displayed so that consumers readily use them for their purchase decision-making. However, the influence of those H-Votes may not be the same depending on contexts. We conducted a pilot survey experiment by using 108 consumers to investigate. The results showed that consumers were not swayed by a positive or negative H-Vote for a top favorable review in Amazon.com. However, consumers significantly voted positively for a top unfavorable (or critical) review in Amazon.com when a negativelybiased H-Vote was shown. To further explore the underlying factors, we deconstructed the YES/NO-based H-Vote with a Likert-scale-based helpfulness rating for (a) product learning and (b) purchase decision-making. While the difference in H-Vote did not affect the learning rating, it did impact the decision rating under a false-negative H-Vote. Implications and future research directions are discussed.
منابع مشابه
Recommending Rating Values on Reviews for Designers
Nowadays, e-commerce Web sites host a large amount of online reviews. Rich information is provided in online reviews. Designers benefit from this information to gain customer requirements. However, there are a large number of online reviews. It makes designers difficult to digest reviews efficiently. In the past few years, many researchers in computer science study how to analyze online reviews...
متن کاملHelpfulness of Online Product Reviews as Seen by Consumers: Source and Content Features
Online product reviews are important determinants of consumers' purchase decision. Although prior research has articulated various benefits of online product reviews, there are few investigations into whether or not they are perceived as helpful by consumers. Product review helpfulness is conceptualized as a second-order formative construct, which is manifested by perceived source credibility, ...
متن کاملExploring Heuristic cues for Consumer Perceptions of Online Reviews Helpfulness: the Case of Yelp.Com
With the prevalence of online reviews, consumers are more inclined to be exposed to an unwieldy glut of information. In contrast to the research on the outcomes of online reviews, recent studies have shifted attention to the antecedents of online reviews, particularly investigating what characteristics lead to a review that is perceived more helpful by online consumers. Our research model of on...
متن کاملBiases in Consumer Reviews: Implications for Different Categories of Goods
Consumers frequently read online consumer reviews before purchasing products both online and offline (at stores). Yet, reviews are known to have certain biases. This paper surveys 17 types of biases that previous studies identified. The effects of these biases are intertwined and hard to isolate from one another. It is then difficult to assess the impact of each bias on how consumers rate the h...
متن کاملInvestigating Determinants of Voting for the "Helpfulness" of Online Consumer Reviews: A Text Mining Approach
The “helpfulness” feature of online user reviews helps consumers cope with information overloads and facilitates decision making. However, many online user reviews lack sufficient helpfulness votes for other users to evaluate their true helpfulness level. This study empirically examines the impact of the various features, that is, basic, stylistic, and semantic, of online user reviews on the nu...
متن کامل